Mass Immigration Destabilizes Western Democracies

Editor’s note: This piece was originally published by Canadians for a Sustainable Society on November 11th.

One issue has caused the largest long term discontent among now restive populations in Western democracies. Globalism, outsourcing and the loss of the best jobs to free trade, are all linked factors but nothing approaches the breadth and depth of the upheaval mass-immigration has caused.

Its compounding impacts of low wages, housing inflation, congestion and a host of social, quality of life and cultural issues are starkly apparent to most people.

Without mass immigration, the social polarization, which is ripping western societies apart, would simply not be happening. At least, not to a degree sufficient to propel someone like Donald Trump into any office higher than that of town councillor. And why wouldn’t the young rebel? They are facing:

  • Debt that can never be repaid
  • Resource depletion that can never be replenished
  • Climate alteration to the point where stabilizing it again may not be possible
  • Greatly increased difficulty in establishing a family

The frustration of the general population is so strong, political wildcards are being embraced as the only option to address fundamental problems deemed unmentionable by current elites. These elites, so certain of their own enlightenment, and obsessed with the growth mantra, simply do not listen or absorb which makes them unable to either learn or innovate. Or lead.

Nations have come to loggerheads with themselves as flame wars and pigeonholing polarize conversation and erode faith in the media and governance. The loss of faith is populism’s feedstock. (Populism) For an increasing proportion of the populace, the mainstream parties are now the anything-but option.

Some of the common impacts of mass immigration, present in varying degrees in all receiving countries, are listed below.

Impacts

  • Housing shortages
    • Increasing demand produces unaffordable housing and more debt
    • Build out on farmland
    • Profitization of housing inflation, foreign ownership
    • Increasing proportion of rental vs ownership
  • Low wages as a huge supply of cheap labour undercuts domestic workers and eliminates the need to invest in improved working conditions and productivity/real wage boosting machinery and methods.
  • Debt saturating every level of society
  • Overloaded social and health services
  • Congestion
  • Increasing inequality via extreme wealth transfer from most people to the very wealthy
  • Decline in the quality of life

These are not declines which would be within the range of a normally functioning, healthy democracy but rather speak to deep, festering, structural problems.

Let’s not talk about it

Impacts whose causes are mysteries to a media industry incapable of connecting the dots:

  • Green belts become a Swiss cheese of developments
  • Unaffordable housing
  • Increase in working poor and intractable poverty
  • Perpetual deficits
  • GHG emissions increases in the face of per capita declines
  • Increase in inequality
  • Crime and no-go areas

Any mention of immigration being at the root of any problem brings media condemnation with the result that expert analysis is either ignored or the authors being intimidated into silence. The resulting yes-men management is incapable of implementing competent policies.

The death of the national conversation means the decline of the democratic system and the growth of extreme parties with narrow platforms from across the political spectrum as broad demographic swaths give up on business-as-usual, mainstream political parties.

Civil conversation and communication has shut down as gerrymandered media is abandoned by those whose well-being has been damaged by the growth lobby. The void is increasingly being filled by a chaotic mix of unedited, unverified, unprofessional and far less fact-based discussion than healthy dialogue demands.

If it isn’t working, tighten the screws

Alarmed establishments react to growing instability with increasingly harsh enforcement of unworkable social policies. They close down voting options when possible – see Justin Trudeau’s 180 on voting reform.

“They’re fearful of having a voting system that doesn’t keep Liberals in power forever more,” said NDP MP Nathan Cullen, who was on a cross-party committee charged with investigating what kind of voting system Canadians would prefer.

The Liberals’ aim to import voters is a ruthless gerrymandering of the political process more egregious than the Republican electoral boundary resetting in the US.

The means of rigging the democratic process are justified by their end of eternal growth which is the simple-minded fantasy that growth will cure all of the problems that growth has actually created. These strategies, from Justin Trudeau’s “the budget will balance itself” to Donald Trump’s “Drill, baby, drill” to push oil down to $40 a barrel, or Mark Carney’s belief in the “power of markets” are biophysically impossible. The immense debt growth is piling up cannot be surmounted by doing more of the same.

Without a focus on increasing per capita income via productivity increase, the only means of retiring the debt is to continue with increased inflation (money printing) as Germany did in their era of social chaos in the 1920s.

Who Benefits from Mass Immigration

  • Speculators turning housing into an international market
  • Cheap labour employers paying minimum wages with minimal benefits and working conditions
  • Predatory nations promoting weakness in the democracies.
    • “Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake” – Napoleon Bonaparte.
    • Social chaos in the West benefits Russian imperial ambitions and they don’t hesitate to throw gasoline on the fire.
  • The finance cult who require asset inflation to acquire wealth rather than producing it

Who has lost in the last 5 decades

Below is a sampling of events in different countries indicating how turbulent and dangerous the current era has become for our democratic systems.

UK

What is the impact of adding millions of people into a small and already crowded nation which is a net importer of virtually every commodity? The Empire no longer supplies all needed raw materials nor is it there to absorb everything England can manufacture.

  • The immigration lobby is so strong it managed to raise intake levels after Brexit even though immigration was the principal driver of discontent leading to the Brexit vote.
  • There are now large open protests with the government countering with draconian restrictions on speech.

Germany

History-cringing Germany is unable to deal with the need to avoid repeating past wrongs and manage the nation’s affairs for the benefit of Germans at the same time. Into this policy vacuum steps the Alternative for Deutschland with now 40+% of the vote.

  • AfD platform
    • Deport the approximately 250,000 foreign nationals who are under a binding obligation to leave the country.
    • Implement “Remigration instead of Talent Poaching”
    • Reverse the mass immigration that has occurred unlawfully and institute “remigration” for regions where hostilities have largely ceased.

Consistent with many right wing populist groups, the policy package seems to include climate denial. Its environmental position is that climate change does not exist. This is a perfect example of a shattered and polarized national conversation.

Sweden

The ultra-liberal state is now dealing directly with the problems created by past excessive hopium.

  • Repatriation is increasingly seen as the solution to unsolvable problems.
  • In the Budget Bill for 2025, the Government presented measures to stimulate voluntary repatriation. These measures include increasing repatriation assistance in 2026. The current system needs to be reviewed in order to enable an increased repatriation assistance up to a maximum of SEK 350 000 or $50,000 CDN.

Spain

Where everyone from north and south want to live or at least own property and vacation.

Nearly 500,000 people protest in Madrid over Spain’s housing crisis caused by mass immigration and foreign ownership. Commercializing the housing sector generates huge profits for banks and speculators but makes housing more expensive and less affordable for citizens.

Asset inflation is a mechanism of wealth transfer from one group to another not wealth creation which can be shared broadly. The young bear the biggest loss of this wealth transfer.

France

Similar to the UK where the concept of being open to the world was one-way in the days of Empire but now it seems openness the other way doesn’t bode well for a functional nation.

  • Rioters protest the failure to enable children from disadvantaged backgrounds to move up the social ladder, the high cost of living and what they say is the deterioration of the social welfare system.

USA

40 years of an immigration/border mess and 12 to 20 million illegals got Donald Trump elected. Unlike the Democratic party elite, or that of the then Republican party, Trump listened. He is going in the right direction to increase real wages and improve productivity but his chaotic implementation undercuts and obscures the methods and the outcomes. And maybe even the goal.

“In Kansas, Democrat Adam Hamilton criticized Biden in a recent debate with Republican Sen. Roger Marshall.

“I want to be crystal clear, first of all: Immigration at the border under Biden was a disaster. That is how we ended up where we are today,” he said.

Trump’s second term has set the high bar for social disruption as strong change initiatives descend into administrative chaos. And then of course, there are the minor details of the undeclared, globally disruptive Iran war, conducted at the behest of a third party nation, Israel, while switching sides in the Ukrainian war and indulging in Nero-like levels of corruption. The Americans first policy has been relegated to the back burner.

Americans are bound to reject this unstable and alarming performance in the midterm elections.

In fact, the Republicans suffered the sharpest repudiation of an American federal government in living memory.

But if so, they will have to squarely address the fundamental problems of which Donald Trump was a symptom rather than the cause by establishing clear leadership and directly attacking the failure which led to the rise of populism.

Australia

Second only to Canada in immigration levels over the past 5 decades, Australia has all of the same lobby and corruption issues inherent in a fast growth, poor social and environmental outcome country.

But Australia does have a rarity in terms of populist expression in the form of greens fielding an integrated environmental, immigration, fiscal, and social policy platform. Sustainable Australia connects the dots and offers a cohesive policy which includes migration reduction. This is basically what science-based Green Parties everywhere should have adopted.

Yet, Australia’s Green Party is pro-mass immigration which effectively cancels all of their environmental policies. This is a conflict common to many Green movements. Their social justice wings have overwhelmed their science grounded policies leaving voters with nothing but wishful thinking and imagineering.

The populist party, One Nation, now sits second in the polls and can likely carry a good deal of their immigration reduction and multiculturalism termination policies forward.

Canada – in more detail

As the country with the highest rate of immigration over 5 decades, (2 to 3 times the rate of the USA) Canada claims the crown for negative impacts on the citizenry and the land. It has them all.

The poster boy for mass immigration added 50% to its population over the past 40 years. With a balanced immigration policy, Canada’s population would now be stabilizing at 28 million as opposed to being 42 million and headed for the Century Initiative target of 100 million by the end of the century.

Like Putin’s 3-day war in Ukraine and Trump’s victory in Iran, Canada’s economy has been world leading according to the finance cult controlled media. The highest GDP growth rate is all the media pundits cover while ignoring the lowest rate of productivity increases. Equality levels fell more than those of any country in the world from the 1960s to now. (#2 to mid-30s)

Impacts

  • The RCMP reports 2000 foreign linked organized crime entities now exist in Canada
  • Housing system is simply broken with 500,000 housing units needed annually for decades – the government might include dog crate condos in their stats but Canadians would not regard these as homes. The housing market is now at a near standstill with few starts and falling prices which, even now, few can afford.
  • Endless construction in increasingly dense cities spills out over some of the best and reliable farmland in the world.
  • Debt – an ocean of debt at all levels, owed by Canadians and held by the finance cult. This is the means of massive wealth transfer.
  • Canadians are fleeing the major immigrant hubs for less expensive, congested and more culturally digestible areas of the country.
  • Greens and NDP are so handcuffed by Pavlovian support for open immigration, they have sidelined their original core objectives of sustainability and living wages.

Environmentally, as one would expect, Canada registered the second worst record of GHG emissions performance of the 57 Kyoto signatories and the highest loss rate of Class 1 agricultural land. There have been no impact assessments on bringing in huge numbers of people despite laws requiring environmental assessment for every major policy. Evasion of such legislated policy procedures is a great deal easier when the nation has no clear goals or coherent strategy.

Going Broke on Growth

  • The cost per kilometer of subways in Toronto has increased from $100 million in the 1960/70s to $1 billion today. Can you guess why?
  • Density increases costs but think of those juicy developer campaign donations!
  • Endless growth means the never ending construction of increasingly complex systems.
  • We are going broke on growth while the growth industry is getting rich.

Meanwhile, Toronto’s average one-way commute time has risen from roughly 20–22 minutes in the 1970s to 34.9 minutes in 2025.

Given the immense increases in spending on transportation infrastructure yet still increasing commute times, does Canada have the most incompetent transportation system designers in the world or is population increase overloading a good system?

Similarly, is the Canadian health system a bad and unworkable system or is it a good system that has been overloaded? Almost certainly the latter. Ditto for many other social and environmental programs. Overloaded systems may not need structural overhauls, they may simply need less pressure.

Rule by Markets – again

Mark Carney’s admirable demeanour is every bit that of the polished, thoughtful and responsible leader (especially when contrasted to Donald Trump) but he is merely the professional version of Justin Trudeau and is a charter member of the finance cult. This elite acquires their wealth by printing money rather than earning it. He and his growth lobby, the Century Initiative, (increase Canada’s population to 100 million by 2100) are now campaigning to wind immigration up to a much more profitable level to “keep the economy growing”, “head off labour shortages”, “fight wage inflation” and “fix ageing”.

The finance cult sees wage growth as a threat while inflating housing costs? – well, they’re “good for the economy” which is finance industry vernacular for finance industry profits.

Contrary to what Carney claims in his book “Values”, printed money and markets will not solve the structural problems mass immigration driven growth has created. Instead of investing in Canadians and conserving resources, the Carney/Liberal plan is to build more houses, highways and infrastructure to expand the commercial market place. While also, of course, pushing up housing costs.

The false God, GDP can no longer be held up as a proxy for economic or social well-being as the last 5 decades of high growth have demonstrated so painfully.

Over the past 40 years growth has been a disaster for the land and the people of Canada while we are moving backward on the transition to progress and on any preparation for looming biophysical challenges.

National Cohesion?

But where are the protests? Most other countries have been rocked by protests and even riots while public dissent in Canada has been minimal with only a few scattered demonstrations. Unfortunately, disenfranchisement has found a more ominous form of expression.

The threat is not just to social order but to the continued existence of the country itself. Separatism is populism regionally expressed, and if things are going as well as the media claims, why are there two strong, credible separatist movements in the country?

There is now a separatist government in Quebec while the Alberta separation referendum received only 25% support from Albertans. But still, how healthy is a country if regionally, ¼ of the people want to separate? Of note in this direct democracy exercise, the only one of the 10 questions to gain majority support was on the reduction of immigration levels. This was clearly supported.

Nothing serves the predatory interests of Putin and Trump better than separatist movements which would shrivel if democratically based, balanced immigration policies were implemented.

Public Opinion

In Canada, public opinion is and has been since the late 1950s, strongly against increasing the population and using immigration to change culture and ethnic makeup. Questions on wanting lower wages, more congestion, less affordable housing, paving over farmland and higher carbon emissions haven’t been asked but surely they don’t need to be.

Canadians, like citizens of every other nation want living wages, affordable housing and a higher quality of life. These aspirations are absolutely fatal to the finance cult whose power and wealth depend on asset inflation and an ever-growing commercial market (GDP). Their fundamental conflict with public interests was known decades ago which is why they bought control of media corporations to manage the national conversation.

Corporate Media / National Broadcasters Chameleon act

The book “Merchants of Doubt” describes how a group of industry connected high-level scientific advisers ran campaigns to mislead the public and deny well-established scientific knowledge over four decades. The same individuals who claim the science of global warming is “not settled” have also denied links between smoking to lung cancer, coal smoke to acid rain, and CFCs to the ozone hole. “Doubt is our product,” wrote one tobacco executive. These “experts” supplied it.

The immigration lobby has never had any data to back up their claims that mass immigration is critical to the well-being of the country. In fact, the record speaks clearly to the contrary. Their view of a country is the size of its commercial marketplace, not how well it runs, how healthy or happy the people are, or if it is in any way socially, fiscally or environmentally sustainable.

The quote below from CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation) is a textbook example of evasion, delay and diversion. In this case, the mission is to support mass immigration and endless growth by questioning its impacts.

“Most of the experts CBC consulted agree that a surge in immigration does contribute to supply and demand issues, but they say it’s important to acknowledge longstanding trends that created these problems.”

Good! No need for any input from citizens and real experts or further investigation by real journalists then. The media claims the moral high ground but they have proven to be “ethically inadequate”.

The damage that falls out of a broken national conversation

Given the narrowness of the finance cult’s view, perhaps one could say they are not lying but they preach their bigger-is-better message from the pulpit of media and government where presenting a broad view of social welfare and holistic policies are absolute fiduciary duties. But that wouldn’t work for them and it was necessary to intimidate whistleblowers and researchers in order to “win”.

Climate change and resource depletion are existential threats to large scale, sophisticated human societies. Hearing the message of change and sacrifice from the same media which has been lying to them for decades on the falsified benefits of mass immigration triggers an instant disbelief response in many people, particularly when the MSM calls daily for more growth.

Both in Canada and globally, the consumption party needs to end but clearly a huge slice of citizens will not accept this message, as long as it comes from the people who have been lying to them about everything else.

Populism isn’t a crime committed by an assemblage of deplorable ingrates; it is a loss of faith. From low wage workers, debt-laden seniors, disaffected youth, to exasperated and increasingly desperate earth scientists, populists come in all political and apolitical stripes. Conversely, for perspective, who still actually believes the democratic system is currently working well?

The growing unrest on display in Western democracies is a symptom of decades of misguided and corrupt policies instituted by disconnected elites who are blind to public interests and deaf to both biophysical expert and grass roots input. We find ourselves with a policy making apparatus frozen by increasingly polarized discussion with communication more focused towards energizing existing bases than finding accommodation with other groups.

Reconnection through progress not growth

The West is faltering because it has no clear goals or means of effectively measuring progress towards them. Turning nations into markets and people into consumers and cheap labour vassals has not resulted in social, environmental or even economic progress yet that is the lens through which policy is still informed.

Never-ending growth was a panacea for several centuries but now, in a changed world, as long as it continues to remain the goal and mass immigration the instrument delivering it, governments will find themselves bereft of tools to address their nations’ worsening structural problems and surging waves of discontent.

The breakdown of democracy has been caused by the decades long erosion of democratic principles and democratic institutions and can only be resuscitated by going direct to citizens in plebiscites whose results will be honoured by government. This is a pill too bitter to swallow for many governments, but it is the only remedy on the shelf to kickstart the meaningful and effective change needed to halt the slide of the democratic West.

Interesting reading:

Democratic institutions must be made relevant in order to reverse social decline.

Daron Acemoglu, a 2024 Nobel prize-winning economist, places immigration at the fulcrum of this reckoning because it brings to the surface a disparate set of cultural questions of shared values, identity and belonging which, if not resolved, drive people into populist waves of illiberalism.

Liberal democracy’s post-industrial crisis – a project that he argues has ceased to deliver on its core promise of sharing economic prosperity by vesting power in the people.

All content on this website is copyrighted, and cannot be republished or reproduced without permission. 

Dominion Review

The truth does not fear investigation.

You can help support Dominion Review!

Dominion Review is entirely funded by readers. I am proud to publish hard-hitting columns and in-depth journalism with no paywall, no government grants, and no deference to political correctness and prevailing orthodoxies. If you appreciate this publication and want to help it grow and provide novel and dissenting perspectives to more Canadians, consider subscribing on Patreon for $5/month. 
- Riley Donovan, editor

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top